Both sandwiches pile griddled beef and melted cheese into a long roll, and both belong to a Northeastern city. The meat is where they split: the Philly cheesesteak uses thin-sliced steak, while the New York chopped cheese is a chopped-up hamburger. The roll, the toppings and the dates behind each sandwich separate them further, and the sources disagree about the chopped cheese’s beginnings in particular.

Video: Is NY’s Chopped Cheese Better Than Philly’s Cheesesteak? from the Ballistic BBQ YouTube channel

The meat and the build

Chopped hamburger against sliced steak

Food Republic sets out the basics. The chopped cheese uses ground beef griddled with onions, American cheese, tomato and shredded lettuce on a long roll that New Yorkers call a hero. The cheesesteak uses thinly sliced ribeye, with American, provolone or Cheez Whiz, and onions ordered “wit” or “witout” on a roll that Philadelphians often call a hoagie roll.

A Philly cheesesteak with thin-sliced steak and melted cheese

Tasting Table adds a table of texture and topping. Cheesesteak peppers and onions are cooked, with little else beyond them, while the chopped cheese carries fresh lettuce and tomato as well as cooked onion, giving a mix of cooked and fresh, with more crunch and acidity. Mashed describes the chopped cheese as meat and cheese mixed into one gooey blend, where the cheesesteak’s cheese melts in a layer over the top.

Cooking technique makes the point. The Daily Meal says the ground beef is cooked on a grill with onions and peppers, chopped with a spatula and covered with American cheese. It advises ordering with American, since that cheese melts well over the chopped beef.

Philadelphia’s side of the story

The Olivieri brothers and a hot dog stand

The cheesesteak has the stronger paper trail. Food Republic credits Pat Olivieri, who ran a hot dog stand and later founded Pat’s King of Steaks, with inventing it in 1930. Tasting Table places it in the 1930s at a South Philadelphia hot dog stand run by Pat and Harry Olivieri, and says cheese was added about a decade after the original, with provolone first. Mashed gives the 1930s as the date and notes the sandwich spread quickly through the sandwich and street food markets.

The history is told in more detail in the site’s posts on the Philly cheesesteak and on Pat’s King of Steaks and Geno’s, where the sources disagree over the exact sequence of events.

The cheesesteak also comes with etiquette. Food Republic says its customization follows tradition, such as not asking for cheddar or pickles, while the chopped cheese is flexible and bodegas let customers add whatever they have in stock.

Harlem and the chopped cheese

A bodega sandwich with no agreed inventor

The chopped cheese is newer and more contested. Food Republic credits Carlos Soto at Hajji’s bodega in Harlem, likely in the 1990s. Tasting Table says the most common account places it in Harlem in the 1990s. Mashed says several vendors from Upper Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn and the Bronx claim it, with Hajji’s Deli among the more prominent, and gives no date.

Ground beef and onions being chopped on a flat-top griddle

The CBS New York report from Hajji’s, at 2135 First Avenue in East Harlem, records two competing stories. Manager Salah Alhubaishi says the shop is the original and that the sandwich draws on Arab food traditions, including his native Yemen, where a similar sandwich is served without cheese. The longtime cook Frankie Frank says he started making it in the 1990s: he was craving a cheeseburger, had run out of buns, and chopped the meat into a hero. A customer noticed, and the sandwich caught on. The report gives no firm creation date.

First We Feast calls Hajji’s, also known as Blue Sky Deli and Grocery, the de facto birthplace, and quotes the rapper Bodega Bamz as saying he first had it in 1996. It reports “Big Frankie” saying he and his late friend Carlos invented it about 15 years before the article, while Alhubaishi says Hajji’s had served it for at least 20 years. The New York Times critic Pete Wells, quoted there, says “Facts are thin on the ground with this sandwich.”

The Yemeni and Midwestern theories

A dish from Yemen, or a loose-meat cousin

Two outside theories surround the sandwich. Alhubaishi suggests, per First We Feast, that it adapted the Yemeni dish dagha yamneeya, chopped meat and vegetables served with Yemeni bread. The Daily Meal repeats the Middle Eastern link, describing the dish as an Arabic meat and vegetable preparation.

Wells sees precedents in Midwestern loose-meat sandwiches, according to First We Feast, but thinks a Philadelphia origin is only slightly more likely. Food Republic says the cheesesteak is older and may have inspired the chopped cheese. The loose-meat family appears in the site’s Maid-Rite post.

A bodega cook quoted by First We Feast describes the chopped cheese as a method instead of a fixed recipe, since steak or roast beef can be used. That description makes the sandwich harder to pin to one inventor, because a method has no first batch.

Price and place

Three-fifty in Harlem, higher elsewhere

First We Feast reports a resident saying a chopped cheese cost $3.50 at Hajji’s, versus $5 for a Philly cheesesteak, and a Chelsea spot charging $6.90 for a hero and $5.90 for a roll. The Daily Meal says bodega versions typically cost $4 to $5, and that upscale versions such as Whole Foods’ 2016 $8 sandwich and April Bloomfield’s $15 version drew backlash. These prices date from the articles’ publication and have likely changed.

A bodega counter with a griddle and hero rolls

Geography shapes both. First We Feast calls the chopped cheese most iconic in Harlem, parts of the Bronx and Queens, with scattered shops in Brooklyn, and says Anthony Bourdain’s Parts Unknown Bronx episode helped introduce it beyond New York. Mashed adds that the cheesesteak appears in the Rocky and Creed films, while the chopped cheese appears in documentaries, First We Feast videos and hip-hop videos, including one Cam’ron filmed at Hajji’s.

Common questions

What is a chopped cheese?

A New York bodega sandwich of ground beef griddled with onions, American cheese, tomato and shredded lettuce on a long roll, as one of the post’s sources describes it.

How does a chopped cheese differ from a Philly cheesesteak?

The chopped cheese uses griddled ground beef, while the Philly cheesesteak uses thinly sliced ribeye, according to the source cited in the post.

Where did the Philly cheesesteak start?

The post covers the Philadelphia claims, including Pat’s King of Steaks, and notes where sources disagree.

Sources

  • Is NY’s Chopped Cheese Better Than Philly’s Cheesesteak? (Ballistic BBQ, YouTube) — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-Yn3_QwdOI
  • Chopped Cheese Sandwiches Are Not At All Like Philly Cheesesteaks (Food Republic) — https://www.foodrepublic.com/1448510/difference-between-chopped-cheese-philly-cheesesteak-sandwich
  • Philly Cheesesteak Vs Chopped Cheese: What’s The Difference? (Tasting Table) — https://tastingtable.com/1567416/cheesesteak-vs-chopped-cheese-difference
  • Chopped Cheese Vs. Philly Cheesesteak: What’s The Difference? (Mashed) — https://www.mashed.com/1405119/chopped-cheese-philly-cheesesteak-difference/
  • Hajji’s Deli in Harlem is known for its chopped cheese sandwich (CBS News New York) — https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/newyork/news/chopped-cheese-the-dig
  • The Cult of the Chopped-Cheese Sandwich, New York’s Most Enigmatic Icon (First We Feast) — https://firstwefeast.com/blogs/eat/the-cult-of-the-chopped-cheese-sandwich-new-yorks-most-enigmatic-icon
  • What You Need To Know Before Ordering Chopped Cheese For The First Time (The Daily Meal) — https://www.thedailymeal.com/1353593/what-need-know-before-chopped-cheese

Keep reading

More in this section: Sandwich Debates guide.